Commercial Real Estate TransactionsChapter 3 · 28 practice questions

Chapter 3: Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

Includes 8 animated diagrams — view them live in the interactive theory reader.

1. Overview of Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

This chapter covers the sale side of commercial practice: how a registrant prepares an office, retail, industrial or commercial condominium property for sale, what the commercial agreement of purchase and sale must address, and how the sale of a business is brokered. It begins with the file that must be assembled before marketing and the documents a buyer of each property type will demand, then works through the clauses specific to commercial transactions — leases assumed on closing, rent and security adjustments, chattels, trade fixtures and equipment, due diligence and environmental conditions — and through the brokering of a business sale: shares or assets, what the seller must deliver, the statements to be provided, the searches a purchaser runs, franchise disclosure, environmental liability, and the representation, disclosure and remuneration obligations that govern the whole file. Modules 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11 and 15 of Course 4. Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Real Estate Transactions.

THE FILE THAT SELLS A COMMERCIAL PROPERTY Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales THE INCOME FILE Rent roll and each lease, with expiry dates Operating costs, realty taxes, recoveries Rentable area and floor plans Capital expenditure and roof or systems work Vacancy, arrears and security held Every figure has a named source THE LEGAL FILE Zoning, official plan and site plan documents Permits issued and the use they authorize Environmental reports and prior uses Declaration and rules for a condominium unit Equipment, chattels, trade fixtures, licences Every limit identified before the offer Why the two files travel together A commercial buyer prices income against constraints. A rent roll without the leases, a lease without the zoning, or a price without the environmental history produces a price nobody can finance. The marketing decision and the legal file are the same decision, taken before the property goes to market rather than during the buyer's due diligence period. The sale file — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.1 Preparing to Sell Office and Retail Property

  • The income file comes first: the rent roll, the rentable area, base and additional rent, expiry and renewal dates, arrears and security held, and the costs behind them.
  • Each lease is read, not summarised: assignment and consent clauses, exclusive uses, co-tenancy rights, percentage rent and relocation or allowance rights change what a buyer pays.
  • The legal file establishes what may be done: the zoning by-law and official plan, the site plan agreement, permits issued and the use they authorize, and how parking and signage are regulated.
  • Marketing describes what has been verified, and the agreement carries the buyer's own verification as a condition rather than leaving it to be discovered after closing.
OFFICE AND RETAIL: WHAT THE BUYER WILL ASK FOR Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales RENT ROLL who, how much, how long, what security, what arrears — the single document the buyer prices first THE LEASES THEMSELVES assignment, exclusive use, co-tenancy, percentage rent, relocation and allowances ZONING AND SITE PLAN permitted use, parking, loading, signage and the conditions that run with the land CAPITAL AND SYSTEMS roof, mechanical and electrical capacity, works done and works outstanding OPERATING COSTS taxes, insurance, common area maintenance and what the landlord actually recovers An unaudited figure presented as a fact is the most expensive sentence in commercial marketing. Preparing the sale — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.2 Preparing to Sell a Commercial Condominium

  • A commercial unit is sold under its declaration and description made under the Condominium Act, 1998, which define the unit, the common elements and its share of common expenses.
  • The by-laws and rules are part of what is sold: they may restrict the business use, hours, signage, deliveries, parking and leasing of the unit.
  • The corporation's records answer the money questions: current and prior budgets, the reserve fund and any study behind it, insurance certificates, financial statements and any assessment.
  • The file holds the declaration, by-laws, rules, budgets, insurance and financial statements, and the buyer's satisfaction of those documents is a condition of the agreement.
A UNIT IS SOLD WITH ITS CORPORATION Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales DECLARATION the unit and its boundaries the common elements the share of common expenses the exclusive-use areas BY-LAWS AND RULES permitted business use hours, signage, deliveries parking and loading leasing restrictions THE MONEY RECORDS budgets, current and prior reserve fund and any study insurance and certificates financial statements The two questions the buyer's lender always asks What are the current common expenses, and is there an assessment or a reserve fund shortfall coming? What does the corporation maintain and insure, and what does the owner insure? A budget that does not fund the reserve fund is a future cost of the unit, and a rule that prohibits the buyer's use is a limit on the price. Both answers come from the corporation's own documents. Commercial condominium — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.3 Preparing to Sell an Industrial Property

  • Equipment and chattels are part of the deal and must be listed: what is included, what the seller retains, what is leased or charged, and what must be certified on closing.
  • Leases in place define the asset in a multi-tenant building; single-tenant premises raise the tenant's remaining term and the buyer's intention to occupy.
  • Building capability is documented, not described: clear height, column spacing, door count and type, floor load rating, power service and spare capacity, sprinklers and yard.
  • The agreement carries the equipment list, the leases, the technical information, the environmental condition and the buyer's inspection right, with adjustments for rents and deposits.
INDUSTRIAL: EQUIPMENT, LEASES, CAPABILITY Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales EQUIPMENT AND CHATTELS What is included and what the seller retains What is leased, financed or under a security interest Attached equipment treated as a trade fixture Equipment to be certified or disconnected CAPABILITY, DOCUMENTED Clear height, column spacing, door count and type Floor load rating, floor slab and drains Power service, spare capacity, sprinkler design Yard, turning radius, outside storage The commercial agreement, built from the file Equipment and chattel list; leases assumed on closing; estoppel or confirmation from the tenants; technical information given to the buyer; environmental condition and reports; buyer's inspection and due diligence; adjustments for rents, security deposits, utilities and taxes; and the conditions O. Reg. 567/05 art. 13.2 to 13.4 requires a written agreement to contain. Every one of these is a document in the file before the offer, not a promise to be settled afterwards. Industrial sale — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.4 The Commercial Agreement of Purchase and Sale

  • The writing rules apply: a clear and understandable written agreement is required, and O. Reg. 567/05, art. 13.2 to 13.4 sets out its content and the copies kept.
  • Leases assumed on closing need more than a statement of assumption: the tenant's confirmation of the lease, the rent and any security held, and no side agreements.
  • Adjustments are provided for: realty taxes, rents, prepaid rent, security deposits, utilities and any improvement allowance, each with the date and method adopted.
  • Conditions carry the buyer's due diligence: financing, inspection, lease and estoppel review, environmental and municipal confirmations, each with a deadline and a waiver mechanism.
WHAT MAKES THE COMMERCIAL AGREEMENT COMMERCIAL Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales LEASES ASSUMED list of leases, tenant confirmation, rent and security, no side agreements CHATTELS AND EQUIPMENT express list of what passes, what is excluded and what is leased ADJUSTMENTS taxes, rents, prepaid rent, deposits, utilities — with the method and the date CONDITIONS financing, inspection, lease review, environmental, municipal — each with a deadline DISSEMINATION AND COPIES the written agreements and copies the regulation requires the brokerage to keep The clause that costs the most when it is missing An adjustment provision with no method or no date becomes a dispute at closing, when neither party has leverage and the money is due. Commercial agreement — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.5 Brokering the Sale of a Business

  • The first question is what is being bought: shares, which carry the corporation with its assets, contracts, employees and liabilities, or assets, which carry only what the agreement names.
  • The structure changes the due diligence and the tax result, and a registrant advises on neither: the client's accountant and lawyer are engaged and the file records that the question was raised.
  • Where a business is sold, O. Reg. 567/05, art. 21 addresses the statements to be delivered and how a brokerage deals with them, and those statements found the buyer's price.
  • The seller must deliver what the agreement and the regulation require, and the buyer must be able to verify it: statements and their basis, contracts, equipment, inventory, licences and employees.
SHARES OR ASSETS: THE FIRST DECISION Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales A SHARE PURCHASE Buys the corporation itself Carries assets, contracts and employees Carries the liabilities, known and unknown No conveyance of land is registered Governed by the Business Corporations Act AN ASSET PURCHASE Buys only what the agreement names Leaves undisclosed liabilities behind Requires consents to assign contracts Registers a conveyance of the land Security interests are searched and released The statements the transaction is priced on Where a business is sold, O. Reg. 567/05 art. 21 addresses the statements to be delivered and how a brokerage deals with them. The registrant's marketing names the source and the period of each statement and never presents a projection as a verified fact: the buyer's accountant and lawyer test the numbers, and the file records that the client was told to engage them. Business sales — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.6 Due Diligence on a Business Purchase

  • Security interests in the assets are searched under the Personal Property Security Act, because equipment, inventory and receivables may already secure a lender's claim.
  • Leases and contracts in progress determine what the buyer inherits or must renegotiate: the premises lease, supply and service contracts, franchise agreements and customer contracts.
  • Employees and their entitlements are part of the price: who is employed, on what terms, what accrued obligations exist, and whether the buyer assumes the payroll.
  • Where the business is a franchise, the Arthur Wishart Act (Franchise Disclosure), 2000 requires a disclosure document within the prescribed period and gives a right to rescind if it is not given.
WHAT THE PURCHASER MUST SEARCH AND READ Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales THE ASSETS Personal Property Security Act searches Equipment leases and financing statements Inventory, receivables and their claims Releases to be obtained on closing THE CONTRACTS The premises lease and its consent clause Supply, service and customer contracts Licences, permits and their transferability Employees, terms and accrued obligations Two disclosures that arrive before the price is agreed A share purchase reaches the corporation's own record under the Business Corporations Act: constating documents, shareholders, directors, minutes, resolutions and any restriction on transferring shares. The buyer inherits the corporation's history with it. A franchise reaches the Arthur Wishart Act (Franchise Disclosure), 2000: the franchisor must give the prospective franchisee a disclosure document within the prescribed period, and a franchisee who does not receive it has a statutory right to rescind. Neither disclosure is the registrant's to give or to summarise: it is identified, requested and passed to the client's advisers. Due diligence — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.7 Environmental Liability Attached to the Land or the Business

  • The land carries the history: a business sale where the operation has used chemicals, fuels, solvents, waste oils or refrigeration transfers a potential environmental liability with the assets.
  • Under the Environmental Protection Act the province may order the investigation, monitoring or remediation of a contaminated site, and an order can reach a present or former owner or occupier.
  • The documents a buyer must obtain or require are an environmental site assessment, tank and spill records, waste manifests, ministry files and the seller's own reports.
  • A contractual indemnity or warranty from the seller does not bind the ministry, so it is taken together with an assessment, a holdback or a condition — not instead of them.
TWO PROTECTIONS, TWO DIFFERENT THINGS Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Transactions and Business Sales THE ORDER UNDER THE ACT Made by the province against a site Can name a present or former owner Can name a present or former occupier Binds whoever is named, whatever the deal says The parties cannot agree it away THE INDEMNITY OR WARRANTY A promise between the parties Worth what the seller is worth Limits and survival period are negotiated Allocates cost between seller and buyer Useful, but not a substitute What the file records What prior uses occupied the site, what reports exist and who prepared them, what remains outstanding, and what the buyer's lender requires. Where the answer is incomplete, the agreement carries an assessment, a holdback or a condition — not an assurance from the registrant. Reassurance is not a registrant's statement to make. Environmental liability — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Transactions and Business Sales

2.8 Representation, Disclosure and Remuneration in a Commercial Transaction

  • Financial benefits and personal interests must be disclosed in writing: O. Reg. 567/05, art. 23.1 requires disclosure of a financial benefit the registrant or an associated person receives.
  • Remuneration must be established in writing under O. Reg. 567/05, art. 23, and in a multi-party commercial deal the file must show who pays what — bulletin 6.2 is the practice reference.
  • Representation is documented under O. Reg. 567/05, art. 13, 13.3.1 and 13.4: who the registrant represents, what services are provided, and the content of the agreement.
  • For a demanding commercial client the value is in the written record: figures with their source, advice with its limits, referrals to the accountant, engineer and lawyer, and every interest disclosed.

3. Important Regulations, Procedures and Provisions

SubjectStatute or ruleWhat it requires
Statements for the sale of a businessO. Reg. 567/05 (TRESA), art. 21Where a business is sold, the regulation addresses the statements to be delivered and how a brokerage deals with them
Written agreements for a tradeO. Reg. 567/05 (TRESA), art. 13.2 to 13.4A written, clear and understandable agreement is required, with prescribed content and treatment of the brokerage's copies
RemunerationO. Reg. 567/05 (TRESA), art. 23Remuneration must be established by a written agreement between the brokerage and its client, including in a multi-party transaction
Disclosure of financial benefitO. Reg. 567/05 (TRESA), art. 23.1A financial benefit the registrant or an associated person receives must be disclosed to the client in writing
Conflicts of interestO. Reg. 365/22The client's interests must be promoted and protected (art. 8) and conflicts of interest, including the registrant's own interest, are governed (art. 13)
The brokering statuteTrust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002The statute that governs the conduct and the agreements of brokerages and registrants in Ontario
Security interests in the assetsPersonal Property Security ActSecurity interests in equipment, inventory and receivables are registered and searchable, so a purchaser searches before agreeing
A share purchaseBusiness Corporations ActThe corporation's constating documents, shareholders, directors, resolutions and transfer restrictions are what a share purchaser examines
Franchise disclosureArthur Wishart Act (Franchise Disclosure), 2000A franchisor must give a prospective franchisee a disclosure document within the prescribed period, and rescission is available if it is not given
Environmental liabilityEnvironmental Protection ActThe province may order the investigation or remediation of a contaminated site, and an order can bind a present or former owner or occupier
Commercial condominium documentsCondominium Act, 1998The declaration, description, by-laws and rules define the unit, its expenses share and the restrictions on its use and leasing
  • Practice points: name the source of every figure before it is marketed; put the buyer's due diligence (leases, estoppels, inspection, environmental, municipal) in the agreement as conditions with real deadlines; and disclose every interest in writing.
  • Where the instruments stop: the regulation requires agreements and disclosures and the code requires honest representation, but no instrument values a business, prices a lease or confirms the condition of a building.

4. Common Relationships Between Concepts

  • Structure of the deal ↔ what the buyer inherits: a share purchase carries assets, contracts and liabilities together; an asset purchase carries only what the agreement names.
  • Rent roll ↔ value: the price is built on rent and cost figures whose source can be named; an unaudited figure presented as fact misrepresents the asset and the seller's position.
  • Lease clauses ↔ price: assignment, exclusivity, co-tenancy and expiry decide what a buyer may do with the property and what a lender will finance, so the leases are the asset.
  • Zoning and site plan ↔ the buyer's use: an operation the by-law does not permit cannot be sold as though it did, whatever the price agreed.
  • Equipment list ↔ closing: chattels and trade fixtures that are not listed expressly are argued about at closing, when the money is already committed.
  • Due diligence conditions ↔ negotiating power: a condition with a deadline and a waiver mechanism converts an unknown into a decision; one without either converts it into a dispute.
  • Security interests ↔ clean title to the assets: an unreleased registration on the equipment follows the goods into the buyer's hands until it is discharged.
  • Environmental order ↔ indemnity: an indemnity allocates the cost between the parties, while an order under the Act binds whoever the ministry names — which is why both are needed.
  • Disclosure ↔ remuneration: what the registrant is paid and what the registrant gains are facts the client is entitled to in writing, and the file that records them is the one that answers an inspection.

This chapter is part of the Ontario Commercial Real Estate Transactions exam preparation material (Module ON-REAL4). The concepts above are tested in the practice questions for this chapter, where commercial sale and business transfer scenarios — the file, the agreement, the business structure, due diligence and disclosure — are applied to the representation of sellers, buyers and business owners.

Ready to train for your real estate exam?

Exam-style questions, timed simulations and the theory for your OACIQ, RECO, BCFSA or RECA exam — pick your plan and start today. The FREE plan costs nothing.

Get Started