Commercial Real Estate TransactionsChapter 2 · 29 practice questions

Chapter 2: Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

Includes 6 animated diagrams — view them live in the interactive theory reader.

1. Overview of Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

This chapter covers the leasing of commercial premises: which statute governs it, what a commercial lease is made of, and what the parties owe each other. It begins with the decisive point — the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 does not govern premises used for commercial purposes and the Commercial Tenancies Act is the statute of general application — then works through the structure of a commercial lease, the obligations of landlord and tenant, the landlord's remedies on default, what a registrant must gather and disclose, permitted use and municipal approvals, and the tenant's work, trade fixtures, restoration and leasing inside a commercial condominium. Modules 12 and 13 of Course 4. Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Real Estate Transactions.

WHICH STATUTE GOVERNS THE TENANCY? Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Leasing and Tenancies THE PREMISES RESIDENTIAL USE Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 rent regulation, statutory notices, Landlord and Tenant Board COMMERCIAL USE Commercial Tenancies Act freedom of contract; the lease decides distress and re-entry regulated Why the choice of statute decides the whole transaction There is no statutory rent control, no prescribed form of notice and no board to apply to: what the lease says is what the parties have, so the registrant must read the whole document — rent, additional rent, term, renewal, repair, insurance and default — and explain it. A client who assumes residential protections has assumed the opposite of the legal position. Governing statute — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

2.1 Commercial Tenancies Are Not Residential Tenancies

  • The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 does not govern premises used for commercial purposes: its protection regime addresses residential units, so a commercial tenancy sits outside it.
  • The statute of general application is the Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7: the parties set their own bargain, and the Act regulates distress, re-entry and relief against forfeiture.
  • The consequences follow from that freedom: no rent control, no statutory right to renew, no prescribed cure period and no board to apply to — the tenant has what the lease grants.
  • So the registrant must read the whole lease with the client — rent, additional rent, term, renewal, assignment, repair, insurance, default — and never describe it in residential terms.
WHAT THE COMMERCIAL TENANT DOES NOT HAVE Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Leasing and Tenancies RESIDENTIAL TENANT HAS BY STATUTE Guidelines-limited rent increases Prescribed notice and cure periods Grounds for termination, and a hearing Security of tenure while the tenancy lasts A landlord duty to maintain the unit COMMERCIAL TENANT HAS ONLY BY LEASE Rent for the term, and renewal only if granted Repair and maintenance as allocated Quiet enjoyment, express or implied Notice periods the lease fixes Relief against forfeiture on application What the registrant must therefore do differently Read the lease in full and explain the clauses that carry cost: additional rent, the tenant's share of taxes and common area costs, repair obligations, insurance, assignment and renewal. Confirm the permitted use against the zoning by-law before the client signs. Never promise a right to renew, a rent review or a protection that the lease does not contain. Where the client needs a right the lease does not give, the answer is a negotiated amendment — in writing, before signature. Tenancy regimes — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

2.2 The Structure of a Commercial Lease

  • Base rent is the fixed annual rent expressed per square foot per year; the rentable area behind it must be defined in the lease, because the multiplication produces the payment.
  • Additional rent is everything else: the tenant's proportionate share of realty taxes, insurance, utilities, common area maintenance and management, as the lease defines the proportion.
  • Deals are described by what they include — net, gross or semi-gross — but the label matters less than the clause allocating each cost.
  • Term, renewal, assignment and security decide the value: an option with its notice period, consent to assign, percentage rent, and the deposit or letter of credit behind the rent.
WHAT A COMMERCIAL LEASE IS MADE OF Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Leasing and Tenancies BASE RENT — per square foot, per year ADDITIONAL RENT — taxes, insurance, costs TERM — start, expiry, fixtures and options RENEWAL — option, notice, rent setting ASSIGNMENT AND SUBLETTING — consent SECURITY — deposit, letter of credit, guarantee The clause that surprises clients: additional rent The tenant's real annual cost is base rent plus its proportionate share of taxes, insurance, utilities, common area maintenance and management. The proportion, the definition of the rentable area and the reconciliation process are what to check — a lease that allows the landlord to fix the share unilaterally has priced the tenancy differently from the one the client modelled. Lease structure — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

2.3 Obligations of the Landlord and the Tenant

  • The landlord's package is usually the base building: quiet enjoyment, roof, foundation and structure, base building systems, compliance of the property with law and insurance of the shell.
  • The tenant's package is the interior and its own operation: interior repair and improvements, utilities, its own liability and contents insurance, compliance as to its use.
  • Insurance is where disputes start: the lease must say who insures the building, who insures the tenant's improvements, what is waived by subrogation and who is an additional insured.
  • The commercial lease is a contract first: the Commercial Tenancies Act does not fill the gaps a residential statute would fill, so an obligation nobody wrote down is owed by nobody.
WHO DOES WHAT: THE ALLOCATION TO CHECK Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Leasing and Tenancies LANDLORD TENANT Quiet enjoyment of the premises Rent and additional rent as they fall due Roof, foundation, structure, base systems Interior repair and its own improvements Insurance of the building shell Liability, contents and business interruption Building compliance with law Compliance as to its own use and operation Common areas, snow, structure of parking Utilities, janitorial, no nuisance to others The gap nobody wrote down Nothing outside the Residential Tenancies Act fills these gaps: a repair obligation, an insurance obligation or a service obligation that the lease omits is not owed by either party. Check the allocation, and amend the lease if the client needs it. Subrogation waivers and additional insured wording are insurance questions for the client's broker, not assumptions for the file. Obligations — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

2.4 Default and the Landlord's Remedies

  • Default is defined by the lease: non-payment of rent or additional rent, failure to perform a covenant, insolvency, abandonment or a use not permitted — with its notice and cure period.
  • Distress allows a landlord to seize and hold the tenant's goods found on the premises for arrears of rent, within the limits the Commercial Tenancies Act imposes on what may be taken.
  • Re-entry, termination and overholding operate as the lease provides and the Act permits, and a tenant facing forfeiture may apply for relief; an improper re-entry exposes the landlord.
  • The registrant's discipline is accuracy about remedies: state what the lease and the Act provide, leave enforcement to the client's lawyer, and promise no removal and no recovery.
DEFAULT: THE SEQUENCE AND ITS LIMITS Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Leasing and Tenancies 1. DEFAULT non-payment, failure to perform, insolvency, abandonment, unpermitted use — as defined by the lease 2. NOTICE AND CURE the notice and the cure period the lease fixes — check them, do not assume them 3. DISTRESS seizure of the tenant's goods for arrears, within the limits of the Commercial Tenancies Act 4. RE-ENTRY AND TERMINATION as the lease provides and the Act permits; overholding is dealt with separately 5. RELIEF AGAINST FORFEITURE the tenant may ask a court to relieve against the forfeiture What a registrant may not promise That a defaulting tenant will be gone by a date, that arrears will be collected, or that a remedy will produce a result. Enforcement is the client's lawyer's work; the registrant states what the lease and the Act provide, and stops there. Default and remedies — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

2.5 Preparing the Commercial Lease: Information and Disclosure

  • From the client: the permitted use it needs, the term and renewal it requires, its rent budget, the work it must do, parking and signage needs, and its insurance and licensing position.
  • From the landlord's file: the lease form and prior leases, the rentable area calculation, operating costs, realty taxes, building rules and any exclusive use that limits the new tenant.
  • From the municipality: the permitted use under the zoning by-law, site plan obligations, the parking requirement, signage limits and the business licence the operation needs.
  • From the regulator's rules: a written representation agreement with the content O. Reg. 567/05, art. 13.4 prescribes, and the information guide delivered and explained before the client commits.
BEFORE THE LEASE: FOUR SOURCES Module ON-REAL4 — Commercial Leasing and Tenancies FROM THE CLIENT Permitted use it needs · term and renewal Rent and additional rent budget Work needed · parking · signage Insurance · licensing · guarantor FROM THE LANDLORD'S FILE Lease form · rentable area calculation Operating costs · realty taxes Building rules · prior leases Exclusive uses and restrictions FROM THE MUNICIPALITY Zoning by-law — use and parking Site plan obligations · signage limits Business licence for the operation Permits issued for the premises FROM THE REGULATOR'S RULES Written representation agreement Content required by O. Reg. 567/05 art. 13.4 Information guide delivered and explained Consent before using another tenant's data Written, dated and on file — the four sources are the difference between advice and a guess. Preparing the lease — ON-REAL4 · Commercial Leasing and Tenancies

2.6 Completing the Lease: Agreement, Remuneration and Representation

  • A commercial lease transaction usually runs through an agreement to lease and then the lease: the agreement fixes parties, premises, term, rent, conditions and work; the lease elaborates the covenants.
  • Disclosure is owed at every stage: what the premises are, what the rent totals with additional rent, what the lease requires of the tenant, and what remains unverified.
  • Remuneration must rest on a written agreement between the brokerage and its client, as O. Reg. 567/05, art. 23 requires, and the commission question is settled in writing before the offer.
  • Advertising must comply with art. 12.1: the brokerage's registered name as prescribed, and no statement that is inaccurate or misleading about the premises or the rent.
  • Representation and ethics govern the file: the client's interests promoted and protected, honesty and accuracy (O. Reg. 365/22, art. 1, 5, 8), under a written representation agreement (art. 13.3.1).

2.7 Permitted Use, Planning and Municipal Approvals

  • The use the tenant intends must be permitted by the zoning by-law: Planning Act, art. 34 lists the uses allowed in each zone, and a lease for a prohibited use creates a real risk for both parties.
  • Site plan control (art. 41) can add conditions affecting the operation — access, parking supply, loading, landscaping, drainage and servicing — all checkable before the tenant commits.
  • Municipal licences and approvals sit outside the lease but on the critical path: business licence, sign permit, patio or outdoor storage approval, a change of use accepted by the building department.
  • Loading, hours, parking and signage are the four operational matters most often assumed and least often verified, and each can make premises unfit for the tenant's business after signature.

2.8 Tenant's Work, Trade Fixtures and Commercial Condominium Units

  • The tenant's work is defined by the lease or a work letter: what the landlord delivers, what the tenant builds, who pays, what approvals are required, and whether the landlord's consent is a condition.
  • Trade fixtures — what a commercial tenant installs to carry on business — ordinarily remain the tenant's property, removable subject to repairing the damage and to the lease and the Commercial Tenancies Act.
  • Restoration is the counterpart: the lease should say what the tenant must remove at the end of the term and what it may leave, because a duty discovered then was never priced.
  • A commercial condominium unit adds the corporation: the declaration, by-laws and rules can restrict use, hours and leasing (O. Reg. 48/01, art. 23), so the tenant needs those documents too.

3. Important Regulations, Procedures and Provisions

SubjectStatute or ruleWhat it requires
The tenancy regimeCommercial Tenancies ActThe statute of general application to commercial tenancies: the parties' lease governs, within the subjects the Act regulates (distress, re-entry, relief against forfeiture)
Residential legislation does not applyResidential Tenancies Act, 2006Its tenancy-protection regime addresses residential units; premises used for commercial purposes are not governed by it
Representation agreementsO. Reg. 567/05 (TRESA), art. 13.4A representation agreement for a lease transaction must be in writing and contain the prescribed content
Advertising the premisesO. Reg. 567/05 (TRESA), art. 12.1Advertising must show the brokerage's registered name as prescribed and must not be inaccurate or misleading
Code of ethicsO. Reg. 365/22Honesty, accurate representation and promotion of the client's interests (art. 1, 5, 8); the former O. Reg. 580/05 was repealed on 2023-12-01
Permitted usePlanning ActThe zoning by-law (art. 34) lists the uses permitted in each zone; site plan control (art. 41) can add conditions affecting access, parking and loading
Leasing a condominium unitCondominium Act, 1998 / O. Reg. 48/01The declaration, by-laws and rules can restrict use and leasing of a unit; art. 23 of the regulation deals with the leasing of units
The tenant's charged assetsPersonal Property Security ActSecurity interests in the tenant's equipment and inventory are registered and searchable, which matters to a landlord's remedy and to a sale of the business
Writing for longer leasesStatute of FraudsLeases and terms of years are void unless made by deed (art. 1); a lease or an agreement for a lease of not more than three years is exempt (art. 3)
  • Practice points: confirm the permitted use against the by-law and the site plan agreement before the tenant signs; show the client the rentable area definition and the additional rent clause; settle commission in writing.
  • Where the instruments stop: the Commercial Tenancies Act regulates specific remedies rather than supplying a tenant-protection code, and no statute sets a commercial rent, a renewal right or a repair standard.

4. Common Relationships Between Concepts

  • Governing statute ↔ the bargain: because the residential statute does not apply, the lease is the whole relationship; a right the lease omits is a right the tenant does not have.
  • Base rent ↔ additional rent: the headline rent is not the tenant's cost, and a proportionate share of taxes, insurance and common area costs can change the decision to lease.
  • Rentable area ↔ rent and share: the definition of the area multiplies both the base rent and the proportionate share, so an undefined area is an undefined obligation.
  • Term and renewal ↔ value: the option and its notice period decide what the tenancy is worth to the tenant and to a buyer of the business, and a missed notice date ends the right.
  • Permitted use ↔ zoning and site plan: an operation that the by-law does not allow, or that the site plan conditions cannot accommodate, cannot be cured by the lease.
  • Insurance ↔ repair: the party who insures and the party who repairs should be the same party, or a loss will be argued about rather than fixed.
  • Default ↔ remedy: the lease's notice and cure provisions decide whether the landlord's remedy is available at all; a remedy exercised outside them creates a liability.
  • Trade fixtures ↔ restoration: the right to remove the tenant's fixtures and the duty to restore the premises are one bargain, and the tenant that takes the first without pricing the second underprices the term.
  • Condominium rules ↔ lease rights: the lease cannot grant what the declaration, by-laws and rules forbid, and the tenant who has not read them has not verified its own permitted use.

This chapter is part of the Ontario Commercial Real Estate Transactions exam preparation material (Module ON-REAL4). The concepts above are tested in the practice questions for this chapter, where commercial leasing scenarios — the lease, its cost structure, default, permitted use and tenant's work — are applied to the representation of commercial landlords and tenants.

Ready to train for your real estate exam?

Exam-style questions, timed simulations and the theory for your OACIQ, RECO, BCFSA or RECA exam — pick your plan and start today. The FREE plan costs nothing.

Get Started