Simulation Session 2: Commercial TransactionsChapter 2 · 50 practice questions

Chapter 2: Commercial Leasing Scenarios

Includes 8 animated diagrams — view them live in the interactive theory reader.

1. Overview of Commercial Leasing Scenarios

This chapter works the commercial lease as a scenario: how a leasing mandate is opened and documented, how base rent, additional rent and the tenant's proportionate share are negotiated, how term, renewal, options, assignment and subletting are structured, who pays for the tenant's work and what happens to trade fixtures and restoration at the end of the term, what the landlord may do when the tenant defaults, how a commercial condominium unit is affected by the rules of its corporation, how the permitted use is checked against municipal approvals, and and how remuneration, representation and disclosure are handled. The Simulation Session publishes no list of modules: the material is the commercial course applied to a leasing fact pattern. Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions.

FROM LISTING TO SIGNED LEASE Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions MANDATE premises, use remuneration OFFER TO LEASE terms negotiated conveyed to the client CONDITIONS financing, use, work landlord's work LEASE rent, term, options deposit in trust Additional rent, the assignment clause and restoration carry the risk Those three are settled before the offer to lease is written Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.1 From Listing to Signed Lease

  • The file opens with the mandate: an agreement with a buyer or seller for the purpose of trading in real estate must include representation.
  • A leasing file identifies the premises and the use, which the rent, the term and the permitted-use clause are built on.
  • The agreement states its dates, services and remuneration, with the expiry date prominent and initialled.
  • The offer to lease is conveyed and the deposit is trust money from receipt, delivered when the agreement requires it.
THE RENT STRUCTURE Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions BASE RENT The headline number Per square foot or per month Set by the term and the market Reviewed at renewal Only the first number ADDITIONAL RENT Realty taxes and insurance Common-area maintenance Utilities and after-hours HVAC Proportionate share, denominator named Estimates reconciled Occupancy cost = base rent + additional rent Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.2 Base Rent, Additional Rent and Proportionate Share

  • Base rent is only the first number: additional rent carries taxes, insurance, maintenance and utilities, and together they are the occupancy cost.
  • The tenant's proportionate share must be defined in the lease, with the denominator named, because the share moves when the building is expanded.
  • Net, net-net and gross leases allocate the same costs differently, so two leases at the same base rent produce different income.
  • Recoverable estimates are reconciled, so the lease says what happens when the actual cost exceeds the estimate.
TERM, RENEWAL, OPTIONS, ASSIGNMENT Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions 1. TERM the landlord's exposure and the tenant's security 2. RENEWAL OR EXTENSION OPTION the notice period and the party who may exercise it 3. ASSIGNMENT the tenant's whole interest, on the landlord's consent 4. SUBLEASE possession for part of the term only 5. CONSENT not to be unreasonably withheld unless the lease says otherwise Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.3 Term, Renewal, Options, Assignment and Subletting

  • The term is the landlord's exposure and the tenant's security, and the lease should say how the rent is set at renewal.
  • An option must be exercised as written: the notice period, the manner of notice and the party who may exercise it are conditions.
  • An assignment transfers the tenant's whole interest; a sublease transfers possession for part of the term, each on the landlord's consent.
  • Consent is not to be unreasonably withheld unless the lease expressly says otherwise, so the clause is read with that proviso.
TENANT'S WORK, FIXTURES AND RESTORATION Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions AT THE START Base building work Tenant improvements Permits and inspections Any allowance paid by the landlord Security interest in the equipment AT THE END Trade fixtures remain the tenant's Removal on the terms of the lease Repair of the damage left Return to shell condition Cost settled before the work begins Restoration is priced before it is incurred Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.4 Tenant's Work, Trade Fixtures and Restoration

  • Who builds what, and who pays, is the first schedule: base building work, the tenant's improvements, permits, and any allowance.
  • Trade fixtures installed by a tenant to carry on business usually remain the tenant's, subject to removal and repair at the end of the term.
  • The restoration obligation is written before the work begins, because the cost of returning the unit to shell condition must be priceable.
  • Equipment bought with borrowed money may carry a security interest, perfected by registration and searched before the buyer relies on it.
REMEDIES WHEN THE TENANT DEFAULTS Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions NON-PAYMENT fifteen days re-entry covenant NOTICE prerequisite to re-entry or forfeiture DISTRESS reasonable; sale after five days and appraisal OVERHOLDING double rent or value writ of possession The statute fixes the remedy; the lease decides the consent that precedes it La loi fixe le recours; le bail décide du consentement qui le précède Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.5 Remedies When the Tenant Defaults

  • Every demise is deemed to include the re-entry covenant: the landlord may re-enter if the rent remains unpaid for fifteen days.
  • Re-entry and forfeiture require notice, and the tenant may apply to the court for relief on the terms the court thinks fit.
  • Distress must be reasonable: goods may be sold five days after the distress and notice, after an appraisal.
  • Holding over costs double — the yearly value, or double rent after a notice to quit — and the landlord may seek a writ of possession.
A COMMERCIAL CONDOMINIUM UNIT AND ITS RULES Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions 1. THE DOCUMENTS DECIDE declaration, by-laws and rules restrict use and leasing 2. NOTICE IN TEN DAYS the lessee's name, the owner's address and the lease 3. SUBLEASE OR ASSIGNMENT counts as a lease for the notice obligation 4. STATUS CERTIFICATE common expenses, any default, the rules that bind 5. BEFORE THE OFFER the certificate is read, not ordered after the condition Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.6 A Commercial Condominium Unit: Rules That Restrict Leasing

  • The corporation's documents decide whether the unit may be leased, and the rules may restrict the use or the manner of leasing.
  • A lease must be reported within ten days, with the lessee's name, the owner's address and a copy or summary of the lease.
  • A sublease and an assignment count as a lease, so the notice obligation follows the transaction and not its label.
  • The status certificate is read before the offer: it states the common expenses, any default and the rules that bind the tenant.
PERMITTED USE AND MUNICIPAL APPROVALS Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions THE LAW Zoning by-law: permitted uses only Site plan control area Plans and drawings approved Building permit for the work Business licence where required THE FILE Written municipal answer Zoning compliance letter Confirmation the use is permitted The tenant's work approved No opinion given by the registrant A use that is not permitted makes the covenant impossible Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.7 Permitted Use and Municipal Approvals

  • Zoning is the first question: a by-law permits only the uses it sets out, so a tenant outside them cannot be advised to sign.
  • Site plan control can govern the tenant's work, because plans and drawings for development are approved by the municipality.
  • A permitted use may still need another approval: a business licence, a sign permit or a building permit for the work.
  • The registrant does not give a zoning opinion and advises the client to obtain the municipal answer.
REMUNERATION, AGREEMENT AND DISCLOSURE Module ON-APP — Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions WRITTEN AGREEMENT representation included dates and services REMUNERATION signed by the payer or on the payer's behalf ADVERTISING registered name permitted terms only REPRESENTATIONS accurate and not misleading No remuneration without a written agreement signed by the payer The same rules apply to a leasing file as to a sale Commercial leasing scenarios — ON-APP · Commercial Leasing Scenarios

2.8 Remuneration, Written Agreements and Disclosure

  • Remuneration is agreed in writing: no remuneration is charged unless the entitlement arises under an agreement signed by the payer.
  • The leasing file is documented like a sale: an agreement with representation, its dates, its services and its remuneration.
  • Advertising follows the advertising rule: the registered name is disclosed and only the permitted terms are used.
  • Representations about the premises must be accurate, and a registrant shall not misrepresent or engage in an unethical practice.

3. Important Regulations, Procedures and Provisions

SubjectStatute or ruleWhat it requires
The commercial tenancy regimeCommercial Tenancies Act, s. 2The Act does not apply to tenancies governed by the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006
Re-entry for non-paymentCommercial Tenancies Act, s. 18Every demise is deemed to allow re-entry if the rent is unpaid for fifteen days
Notice and reliefCommercial Tenancies Act, ss. 19, 20Notice is a prerequisite to re-entry or forfeiture, and the lessee may apply for relief
AssignmentCommercial Tenancies Act, s. 23A covenant against assignment without consent is subject to a proviso that consent is not unreasonably withheld
DistressCommercial Tenancies Act, ss. 43, 53, 55Reasonable distress, sale after five days and an appraisal, damages for excessive distress
Overholding and bankruptcyCommercial Tenancies Act, ss. 38, 58, 59, 74A limited preferential lien, double rent or value for holding over, and a writ of possession
The tenant's goodsPersonal Property Security Act, ss. 19, 23, 28, 34Registration perfects a security interest, an ordinary-course buyer takes free, and a fixture may be removed
Permitted usePlanning Act, ss. 34, 41A zoning by-law permits only the uses it sets out; site plan control over plans and drawings
Leasing a condominium unitCondominium Act, 1998, s. 83; O. Reg. 48/01, s. 23Notice to the corporation within ten days, and a sublease counts as a lease
Representation and advertisingO. Reg. 567/05, ss. 12.1, 13.4The registered name and permitted terms; a written agreement with dates and remuneration
Remuneration and accuracyO. Reg. 567/05, s. 23; O. Reg. 365/22, ss. 1, 5Remuneration under a signed agreement; accurate, non-misleading representations
  • Practice points: a commercial lease is negotiated, not filled in — the risk sits in the additional rent, the assignment clause and the restoration obligation.
  • Where the registers stop: a lease is a contract, not a registration; the personal property registry shows a security interest, not the landlord's consent.

4. Common Relationships Between Concepts

  • Residential tenancy ↔ commercial lease: that Act governs residential units, so the parties rely on their contract and the Commercial Tenancies Act.
  • Base rent ↔ additional rent: a tenant who fixes the first without capping the second has not fixed the occupancy cost.
  • Term ↔ renewal option: the term fixes the exposure and the option fixes the choice, so an option exercised outside its notice period is not an option.
  • Assignment clause ↔ deemed proviso: consent is not to be unreasonably withheld unless the lease says otherwise, so a bare clause gives the tenant more than intended.
  • Tenant's work ↔ trade fixtures: work and fixtures become part of the premises, so the lease says who removes them and who repairs the damage.
  • Default ↔ remedies: non-payment opens re-entry after fifteen days, distress and a writ of possession, so the remedy is chosen in the lease and in the statute.
  • Permitted use ↔ zoning and site plan: the lease promises a use the by-law must permit, so a use outside the by-law makes the covenant impossible rather than breached.
  • Condominium rules ↔ leasing plan: the rules can restrict leasing and a lease must be reported within ten days, so the plan is checked against them.

This chapter is part of the Ontario real estate simulation examination preparation material for Simulation Session 2: Commercial Transactions (Module ON-APP). The concepts above are tested in the practice questions for this chapter, where commercial leasing scenarios are applied to the representation of a landlord, a tenant and a purchaser of a leased property.

Ready to train for your real estate exam?

Exam-style questions, timed simulations and the theory for your OACIQ, RECO, BCFSA or RECA exam — pick your plan and start today. The FREE plan costs nothing.

Get Started