Why the Offer Sequence Carries So Many Marks
Every provincial licensing exam devotes a block to the transaction documents, and the questions cluster around one idea: at what point a negotiation stops being a conversation and becomes a contract. Four documents carry four names for the same act. Quebec calls it the promise to purchase and the counter-proposal, and both are OACIQ forms in residential brokerage since the June 10, 2022 amendments made written forms mandatory. Ontario calls it the Agreement of Purchase and Sale, and the standard version is OREA Form 100. British Columbia uses the Contract of Purchase and Sale, published jointly by the BC Real Estate Association and the Canadian Bar Association British Columbia Branch for use in BCFSA-regulated practice. Alberta uses the Residential Real Estate Purchase Contract published by the Alberta Real Estate Association and used across RECA-licensed practice. The exam tests the vocabulary first and the sequence second. A listing price is an invitation to treat, not an offer. A contract needs offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity and legality, and a candidate who can point to where each element sits inside the form can answer most of the questions in this section.
Quebec: Irrevocability, the Deposit and the Counter-Proposal
The OACIQ promise to purchase (Promesse d'achat - Immeuble) is drafted so the buyer commits first and the seller answers. Clause 14.1 records that the buyer is irrevocably bound until a stated hour and date. If the seller accepts within that time, the promise becomes a contract binding both parties; if the seller does not accept within that time, it becomes null and void. Article 1390 of the Civil Code of Quebec supplies the reason: where a term is attached to an offer, the offer may not be revoked before the term expires, and article 1392 adds that an offer lapses if no acceptance is received before that term expires. The deposit lives at clause 4.3. The buyer pays the broker named at clause 2.1, called the fiduciaire, by cheque or electronic transfer made out en fidéicommis, and the money is deposited without delay into the brokerage trust account and receipted; if the promise becomes null and void, the trustee must refund it without interest on a written request, and otherwise may deal with it only as the promise or the law allows. Clause 8 carries the inspection condition, clause 6 the financing condition, and clause 9 the review of documents, which in a divided co-ownership reaches the declaration of co-ownership, the minutes, the insurance and the contingency fund. Inclusions and exclusions sit at clauses 11.5 and 11.6. Anything else, including a condition tied to the sale of the buyer's own property, has to be written into clause 12. The counter-proposal is a separate form, the Contre-proposition à une promesse d'achat. Its clause P2.2 declares every previous counter-proposal null and void, and the promise itself says at clause 14.1 that any counter-proposal by the seller has the same effect as a refusal. That sentence answers a question that appears in some form on almost every Quebec paper: a counter-proposal does not improve the first offer, it ends it. Clause P2.4 adds a counter-proposal conditional on the cancellation of a first promise already accepted.
Ontario: Form 100, Conditions and the Competing Offer Rule
Ontario's standard form is OREA Form 100, and the exam treats its clauses as a checklist. Clause 1 is irrevocability: the offer states the exact time and date until which it stands, and after that time, if it has not been accepted, it is null and void. A counter-offer in Ontario is a new offer, so acceptance of the original must happen before the counter-offer is made, and once it is made the original is gone. The deposit is a negotiable cheque payable to the deposit holder and held in trust pending completion or other termination of the agreement, which makes it evidence of good faith, not consideration. Conditions are written into the agreement and answered formally: OREA Form 124 is the Notice of Fulfillment of Condition(s) and Form 123 is the Waiver, and either has to be signed and delivered before the deadline, because a verbal waiver does nothing. Condominium resale uses Form 101, which carries the status certificate condition. Competing offers are where the exam tests the line between number and content. Under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 and RECO's guidance, the number of competing offers must be communicated to every person making one of them, while the content may be shared only if the seller directs in writing, and then it must go to everyone making an offer, with personal and identifying information removed.
British Columbia and Alberta: Subject Clauses and the Condition Day
British Columbia's Contract of Purchase and Sale frames conditions in the buyer's favour as subject clauses. The form fixes the deposit amount and the number of hours within which it must be paid after acceptance, and it fixes a date for subject removal. Deposits sit under the Real Estate Services Act, which requires money received by a brokerage in respect of a trade to be held in trust, and BCFSA describes the brokerage as stakeholder, so where the buyer does not remove the subject clauses the brokerage still needs a signed release from both parties before it can pay the money out. British Columbia also added a statutory layer: under section 42 of the Property Law Act and the Home Buyer Rescission Period Regulation, a buyer may rescind within three business days of acceptance and pays a rescission fee of 0.25 per cent of the purchase price, which the brokerage takes from the deposit before returning the balance. Alberta works differently, and the vocabulary is the giveaway. The Residential Real Estate Purchase Contract sets a Condition Day for each condition: if the condition is not satisfied or waived in writing by that date, the contract is undone and the deposit goes back; if it is satisfied or waived, the contract becomes fully binding. The AREA contract also carries a deposit dispute clause under which a brokerage that cannot determine entitlement notifies the parties and may pay the money into a lawyer's trust account. Alberta practice runs through conditions as much as through price, so an Alberta question often turns on the Condition Day rather than on the offer itself.
How Scenarios Are Written, and the Line Between Advising and Negotiating
The scenario questions repeat a small number of traps. One is reviving an offer whose acceptance time has passed, and the answer is no, because a lapsed offer is dead and what follows is a new one. Another is the belief that a deposit is what makes a contract enforceable, when consideration is supplied by the mutual promises and the deposit is protection and evidence. A third is the idea that an agreement conditional on financing or inspection is not yet binding, when the parties are bound from acceptance and only the conditions remain open. A fourth is drafting so subjectively that the condition collapses, as in a clause subject to the buyer's sole and absolute discretion. A fifth is disclosure in a multiple offer file, where the exam separates the number of offers, which is disclosed in Ontario, from their content, which requires the seller's written direction, and from Quebec, where the seller's broker must tell the other brokers that a promise exists but may not reveal what it says. A licensee advises on price, conditions, deposit size, dates and risk, explains what each clause means, and presents every offer promptly and in full; the client decides. Negotiating on a client's behalf means acting on authority the client has granted, and even then the licensee does not sign for the client, does not accept an offer for the client, cannot invent facts about a property, and cannot use one client's confidential information to advantage the other side. A question that asks whether the licensee should accept a counter-offer on the client's behalf has one answer: no, that decision is the client's, and it is delivered in writing.